The final chapter explores the theme “Live and let live”. The beauty of this chapter is that it raises the argument that Dawkins does not seem to agree with himself. Ironically, Dawkins is scathing about the dangers of certainty yet seems to overlook the dangers of atheistic fundamentalism. Dawkins is quite certain that we should take courage in both hands and give up on all gods, yet surely even he couldn’t disagree with Socrates’ great insight that “the key to wisdom is not how much you know but having some understanding of the limits of your knowledge.”
If this book helps the reader to have some arguments at hand to help counter those conversations you may have with sceptics, then that is where I see its main benefits. Have you considered this, have you considered that, did you know that Dawkins arguments do not include x for example? It provides ideas to help you encourage others to go away and at least read Dawkins’ books with a more critical eye. Would it persuade an atheist on a first read? No, it wouldn’t, but there is a well referenced Notes section at the back for readers to read more deeply if they wish.
The Rev’d Dr Jenny McKay
Veterinary Pathologist and Curate at St Mary and All Saints’, Great Budworth, Cheshire.